By Prof. Gitile Naituli
William Ruto took credit for a stronger shilling in Parliament today. Fair enough. Let him now accompany a Kenyan parent to the shop and spend it. Let him buy milk, ask the price of a tray of eggs and see what remains for tomorrow’s fare. I would gladly hear a second State of the Nation address from him on the walk home. By then, the President and his audience would at least be discussing the same shilling.
In his final address before the 2027 election, Ruto told Parliament that the shilling had recovered from nearly 162 to about 129 against the dollar. He spoke about bringing down living costs and raising incomes. Those issues got a mention. What Kenyans deserved was an explanation of how a government claiming such success could preside over an economy in which so many households have lost ground. In a TIFA survey, nearly two thirds said their circumstances had worsened since 2022. Only 12 per cent reported an improvement.
I have no quarrel with the arithmetic of economic growth. The Parliamentary Budget Office puts real growth at 5.1 per cent in the first half of 2026. My quarrel is with the political use to which that figure is put. Building a stadium creates work and adds to national output. The same statistic cannot tell us whether the tender was competitively priced, whether the stadium will earn its upkeep or whether repairing a road used by thousands of farmers would have yielded a better return.
Consider the mason who lays the stadium’s last block. His labour appears in the national accounts. On Monday morning, when the contractor has packed up, he must find another site. Who pays him if he falls ill between jobs? What pension contribution follows him from one contractor to the next? The World Bank reports that 83.8 per cent of jobs were informal in 2025. A government that counts every worker at the groundbreaking ought to show some curiosity about where those workers go.
Then there is the bill for all this progress. The World Bank puts public debt at 70.6 per cent of GDP and estimates that interest absorbs roughly a third of government revenue. Imagine collecting three shillings and handing one to a lender before buying a textbook or stocking a dispensary. The principal is still owed. When the President invites us to admire a new road, I want to know its final cost, the interest due and whose budget will carry the maintenance.
At the Nairobi pump, diesel is Sh227.76 a litre. A farmer who has never owned a vehicle still pays part of that bill every time a lorry takes produce to market. The shopkeeper pays to bring the eggs in. The customer pays to take them home. Add the electricity needed to keep milk cold, and the price pencilled on the shopkeeper’s carton begins to tell a fuller economic story than the exchange rate displayed behind a bank counter.
Housing provided the President with another handsome exhibit. He credited the programme with creating 1.1 million jobs. I would like him to introduce Parliament to a construction worker who has bought one of the flats on the strength of what he earned building it. How much did he save for the deposit? What instalment falls due in a month when work dries up? Parliament’s own budget analysts observed that registering on Boma Yangu establishes interest while leaving the applicant’s ability to pay an open question. Affordable to whom, Mr President?
There is one measure of national wellbeing for which no economist is required. Can a family say where its child is tonight? Missing Voices documented 125 cases of police killings and six enforced disappearances in 2025 alone. This month, lawyer Abshir Abdi was found alive in Marsabit eleven days after armed men reportedly took him in Nairobi. Thank God he came home. Who took him? Where was he held? Who will answer for the days his family spent wondering whether he was alive?
I worry about what a young Kenyan learns from all this. A minister can defend a costly project before television cameras and go home under guard. A citizen who questions that expenditure must consider whether to join a demonstration, whether to take a phone and what to tell the children before leaving home. A president seeking credit for national transformation should care deeply whether citizens feel safe enough to tell him he has failed.
William Ruto cannot divorce himself from the consequences of his maladministration. He asked Kenyans to trust his judgement about what to build, what to borrow and what they could afford to pay. They are entitled to judge him by what those decisions have left in their pockets and by the freedom they enjoy to question him. A stadium photographs beautifully. An empty place at the family table is usually visible only to the people sitting around it.
Mr President, many Kenyans may never afford the houses they helped you build. They can still afford a smile. When August comes, the worker who laid the blocks and the President who unveiled the plaque will each have one vote. On that day, the mason gets to tell you whether the job is finished.
Comments